The 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom is an iconic American cruiser motorcycle, part of the legendary Sportster lineage dating back to 1957. Featuring a classic V-twin body style, this model falls within the rubber-mounted engine era (2004-2020), offering improved ride comfort. Key trims in the Sportster family include 883 and 1200 variants like the Roadster, Low, and Custom. New in 2005, it retailed around $9,500-$10,000, and used prices today typically range from $4,000-$7,000. It stands out for its timeless styling, accessible "big twin" feel, and immense customization potential, making it a popular entry into Harley-Davidson ownership.
The Good
The 2005 Sportster 1200 Custom offers adequate performance with its torquey Evolution V-twin. Its robust design contributes to solid reliability, while the rubber-mounted engine significantly enhances comfort by reducing vibrations. The timeless Harley design and signature exhaust note appeal to emotional buyers, providing brand prestige and a sense of freedom. Practical buyers appreciate its decent fuel economy, strong resale value, and extensive aftermarket support, making it an accessible and enjoyable cruiser.
The Bad
Known weaknesses include its basic suspension, which can be harsh on rough roads, and limited comfort for extended touring compared to larger bikes. The single-disc brakes are adequate but not high-performance. Watch out for potential oil leaks from aging gaskets, typical of older Harleys, and occasional electrical gremlins with the charging system or wiring harness over time. The smaller fuel tank on some Sportsters can limit range.
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom: Quick Overview
- Engine: Air-cooled, 1200cc Evolution V-Twin (45-degree).
- Horsepower: Approximately 67-70 hp (50-52 kW) at 5,200 rpm.
- Torque: Around 79 lb-ft (107 Nm) at 3,500 rpm.
- Fuel Economy: Estimated 45-50 MPG combined, depending on riding style.
- 0-60 MPH: Approximately 4.5-5.0 seconds (estimated, not officially published for motorcycles in the same manner as cars).
- Towing Capacity: Not applicable for motorcycles; not designed for towing.
- Trim-Level Features (1200 Custom - XL1200C):
- Chrome engine covers and extensive chrome accents throughout.
- Laced (spoke) front wheel (13-spoke cast on some markets), solid disc rear wheel.
- Forward-mounted foot controls for a relaxed riding posture.
- Pull-back handlebars providing a cruiser feel.
- Custom tank graphics and badging.
- Two-up seat, allowing for a passenger.
- Large 4.5-gallon fuel tank, offering better range than the standard 3.3-gallon.
- Chrome staggered shotgun exhaust system.
- Low-profile front fender.
- Basic instrumentation with a tank-mounted speedometer and odometer, indicator lights.
- Single disc front brake and single disc rear brake.
- Five-speed transmission.
- Belt final drive for smooth power delivery and reduced maintenance.
- Rubber-mounted engine, a significant upgrade from 2004, designed to reduce engine vibration transferred to the rider.
- Chrome engine covers and extensive chrome accents throughout.
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Specifications
Vehicle Information
| Year | 2005 |
| Make | Harley-Davidson |
| Model | Sportster 1200 Custom |
| Trim | - |
| Style | - |
| Type | Motorcycle |
| Category | Motorcycle |
Manufacturing Details
| Made In | United States |
| Manufacturing City | KANSAS CITY |
Dimensions
| Doors | - |
| Curb Weight | - |
| Gross Vehicle Weight Rating | - |
| Overall Height | - |
| Overall Length | - |
| Overall Width | - |
| Wheelbase Length | - |
| Standard Seating | - |
Engine & Performance
| Engine | 1200-CC |
| Engine Size | 1200L |
| Engine Cylinders | 2 |
| Transmission | - |
| Transmission Type | - |
| Transmission Speeds | - |
| Drivetrain | - |
Additional Features
| Anti-Brake System | - |
| Steering Type | - |
Pricing
| Manufacturer Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) | - |
| Invoice Price | - |
| Delivery Charges | - |
Vehicle History Report
Vehicle
Specifications
Specifications
Ownership
History
History
All History
Events
Events
NMVTIS Title
History Check
History Check
Salvage/Rebuilt
Check
Check
Accident
Check
Check
Theft
Check
Check
Open Lien
Check
Check
Past Sale
Listings
Listings
Safety
Recalls
Recalls
Odometer
Check
Check
Market Price
Analysis
Analysis
What Problems Does the 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Have?
The 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom, while generally robust, has a few frequently reported issues common to its age and design. Oil leaks are a classic Harley concern, often originating from rocker box gaskets, primary cover gaskets, or stator grommets as seals degrade over time. While the Evolution engine is an improvement, these can still occur. Electrical problems are also not uncommon; owners sometimes report issues with the stator or voltage regulator leading to charging system failures, which can drain the battery or cause intermittent lighting issues. Wiring harnesses, especially around the steering head, can suffer from chafing or corrosion, leading to various electrical glitches.
Being a carbureted model, the Keihin CV40 carburetor may require cleaning or tuning over the years due to fuel deposits, especially if the bike sits unused for extended periods. Ignition switch failures, where the switch becomes stiff or loses proper contact, are also reported. Stock suspension components, particularly the rear shocks, can wear out and lead to a harsher ride. Fork seal leaks are another common maintenance item.
Regarding recalls, the 2005 Sportster models were subject to at least one significant recall (NHTSA Recall 05V-414). This recall addressed a potential issue where the speedometer and indicator lights could become inoperative, depriving the rider of crucial information such as speed, fuel level, and turn signal operation. Another related to potential fuel tank leaks. Long-term reliability of the Evolution engine is generally strong, with many examples exceeding 50,000 to 100,000 miles when properly maintained. Most concerns are wear-and-tear related rather than catastrophic failures, highlighting the importance of diligent maintenance to mitigate these age-related issues.
Being a carbureted model, the Keihin CV40 carburetor may require cleaning or tuning over the years due to fuel deposits, especially if the bike sits unused for extended periods. Ignition switch failures, where the switch becomes stiff or loses proper contact, are also reported. Stock suspension components, particularly the rear shocks, can wear out and lead to a harsher ride. Fork seal leaks are another common maintenance item.
Regarding recalls, the 2005 Sportster models were subject to at least one significant recall (NHTSA Recall 05V-414). This recall addressed a potential issue where the speedometer and indicator lights could become inoperative, depriving the rider of crucial information such as speed, fuel level, and turn signal operation. Another related to potential fuel tank leaks. Long-term reliability of the Evolution engine is generally strong, with many examples exceeding 50,000 to 100,000 miles when properly maintained. Most concerns are wear-and-tear related rather than catastrophic failures, highlighting the importance of diligent maintenance to mitigate these age-related issues.
How long will the 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom last?
With diligent maintenance, a 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom can easily achieve 50,000 to 100,000 miles, and many well-cared-for examples exceed this. It's not uncommon to see these bikes still ridden regularly after 15-20+ years of service. The Evolution engine is renowned for its long-term durability and robust design.
However, several weaknesses emerge over time. Gaskets and seals, particularly around the rocker boxes and primary cover, can eventually dry out and lead to minor oil weeping or leaks. Electrical components like the stator, voltage regulator, and battery are common failure points as they age. Stock suspension components will wear out, warranting replacement or upgrades for improved ride quality. Chrome finishes may pit or peel if not regularly cleaned and protected. Carburetor maintenance, including cleaning and jetting, becomes more critical with age and varying fuel quality. Regular inspection of fuel and vacuum lines for cracking or degradation is also essential for safe, reliable operation.
However, several weaknesses emerge over time. Gaskets and seals, particularly around the rocker boxes and primary cover, can eventually dry out and lead to minor oil weeping or leaks. Electrical components like the stator, voltage regulator, and battery are common failure points as they age. Stock suspension components will wear out, warranting replacement or upgrades for improved ride quality. Chrome finishes may pit or peel if not regularly cleaned and protected. Carburetor maintenance, including cleaning and jetting, becomes more critical with age and varying fuel quality. Regular inspection of fuel and vacuum lines for cracking or degradation is also essential for safe, reliable operation.
What Technology & Safety Features are Included?
As a 2005 motorcycle, the Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom is decidedly analog, prioritizing raw riding experience over advanced electronics. Its "built-in tech" is quite basic, comprising a tank-mounted speedometer with an odometer and a set of simple indicator lights for neutral, oil pressure, high beam, and turn signals. There is no tachometer or sophisticated multi-function display. The fuel system is carbureted (Keihin CV40), requiring a manual choke for cold starts, distinguishing it from later fuel-injected models. Lighting consists of a halogen headlamp and incandescent turn signals and tail light. The ignition is a traditional key-based system.
Entertainment features are nonexistent as standard; any audio or communication system would be an aftermarket addition, typically integrated into a rider's helmet. Driver-assistance technologies like ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), traction control, stability control, or cruise control were not available on this model. The riding experience is pure and unassisted, relying entirely on the rider's skill and input.
Safety features are fundamental: single disc brakes at both the front and rear, standard lighting (headlamp, tail light, turn signals), and a horn. Motorcycles, including the Sportster, are not subjected to official crash-test ratings by organizations like NHTSA or IIHS in the same way automobiles are. Rider safety is heavily dependent on personal protective equipment, rider skill, and adherence to safe riding practices. Optional features typically offered by dealers or the factory included security systems, detachable windshields, sissy bars/backrests, saddlebags, engine guards, various custom seats, and a wide array of chrome and performance accessories, allowing for extensive personalization.
Entertainment features are nonexistent as standard; any audio or communication system would be an aftermarket addition, typically integrated into a rider's helmet. Driver-assistance technologies like ABS (Anti-lock Braking System), traction control, stability control, or cruise control were not available on this model. The riding experience is pure and unassisted, relying entirely on the rider's skill and input.
Safety features are fundamental: single disc brakes at both the front and rear, standard lighting (headlamp, tail light, turn signals), and a horn. Motorcycles, including the Sportster, are not subjected to official crash-test ratings by organizations like NHTSA or IIHS in the same way automobiles are. Rider safety is heavily dependent on personal protective equipment, rider skill, and adherence to safe riding practices. Optional features typically offered by dealers or the factory included security systems, detachable windshields, sissy bars/backrests, saddlebags, engine guards, various custom seats, and a wide array of chrome and performance accessories, allowing for extensive personalization.
What Colors Options are Available?
We’re working on this section!
In the meantime, feel free to explore the other sections for more content.
In the meantime, feel free to explore the other sections for more content.
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Prices and Market Value
When new in 2005, the Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom typically had an MSRP ranging from approximately $9,500 to $10,000, depending on color options and minor factory add-ons. In today's used market, prices vary significantly but generally fall between $4,000 and $7,000. Exceptional, low-mileage examples with thorough maintenance records may command slightly more, while those needing extensive work will be less.
Harley-Davidson motorcycles, especially Sportsters, demonstrate relatively strong resale value compared to many other brands, experiencing initial depreciation but then stabilizing. The 2004+ rubber-mounted engine models, like the 2005, are particularly sought after. Key factors affecting resale value include the bike's overall condition (cosmetic and mechanical), mileage, completeness of maintenance records, and the nature of any customizations. Tasteful, high-quality modifications can enhance value, but overly personalized or poorly executed changes can detract from it, with stock or easily reversible mods often fetching the best prices.
Harley-Davidson motorcycles, especially Sportsters, demonstrate relatively strong resale value compared to many other brands, experiencing initial depreciation but then stabilizing. The 2004+ rubber-mounted engine models, like the 2005, are particularly sought after. Key factors affecting resale value include the bike's overall condition (cosmetic and mechanical), mileage, completeness of maintenance records, and the nature of any customizations. Tasteful, high-quality modifications can enhance value, but overly personalized or poorly executed changes can detract from it, with stock or easily reversible mods often fetching the best prices.
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Cost of Ownership
Insurance for a 2005 Sportster 1200 Custom is generally moderate, as it's not considered a high-performance or high-theft risk motorcycle, though individual rates vary. Fuel costs are manageable, with an average economy of 45-50 MPG on regular unleaded. Maintenance, particularly routine tasks like oil changes and belt tension adjustments, is relatively straightforward and can often be performed by a DIY owner, saving on labor. Parts are widely available through Harley dealers and aftermarket suppliers. Repair costs can be higher if major work is needed and performed by a dealership, but independent Harley specialists often offer more competitive rates. Overall, the 2005 Sportster 1200 Custom is a moderately economical motorcycle to own. It's less expensive than larger Harleys and boasts good long-term durability with proper care, making it a reasonable long-term investment for the brand experience.
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Fuel Efficiency
Fuel Type
Gasoline
Fuel Capacity
-
City Mileage
-
Highway Mileage
-
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Warranty
Basic
Original warranty
0 months / No data
Estimated remaining
Expired
Powertrain
Original warranty
0 months / No data
Estimated remaining
Expired
Rust
Original warranty
0 months / No data
Estimated remaining
Expired
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Insurance
Insurance for a 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom is moderately priced, reflecting its status as a Motorcycle with strong safety ratings and
reasonable repair costs.
reasonable repair costs.
How Does the 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Compare to Other Motorcycle?
The 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom competes primarily against mid-size Japanese cruisers like the Yamaha V-Star 1100, Honda Shadow 750/1100, Suzuki Boulevard C50, and Kawasaki Vulcan 900. In terms of performance, the 1200 Custom's air-cooled Evolution V-twin delivers strong low-end torque and sufficient power for cruising, offering a distinct V-twin rumble that many riders prefer. While some 1100cc+ Japanese rivals might edge it out slightly in horsepower figures, the Sportster's characterful power delivery is unique. However, its basic suspension and braking are outclassed by more modern or performance-oriented cruisers.
Regarding features, the Sportster is quite spartan. Most Japanese rivals from this era, while also largely analog, might offer slightly more refined instrumentation or shaft drive instead of a belt. Modern amenities like ABS or advanced rider aids are absent on the 2005 Sportster, a common trait for bikes of its vintage across brands. The Sportster's "feature" is its iconic styling and immense aftermarket customization potential.
For reliability, the Sportster's Evolution engine is robust, but it can demand more attention to aging gaskets and seals than some Japanese counterparts, which are often lauded for their bulletproof, low-maintenance reliability. However, the Sportster's simplicity often means easier diagnosis and repair for common issues. In terms of price, the Sportster typically commanded a higher new price than comparable Japanese cruisers. In the used market, it generally holds its value better, often selling for a premium due to the Harley-Davidson brand cachet.
Similar Alternatives: The Yamaha V-Star 1100 Custom offers similar cruiser aesthetics and solid performance, often at a slightly lower used price. The Honda Shadow Aero 750 or Spirit 1100 are also strong contenders for reliability and classic looks. The Kawasaki Vulcan 900 Custom provides good value with a modern liquid-cooled engine and comfortable ride.
Better Alternatives: "Better" depends on priorities. For modern features like ABS, fuel injection, and greater refinement, newer bikes from any brand would be superior. For long-distance comfort, larger Harley models (Dyna, Softail, Touring) or touring-oriented Japanese cruisers would be far more suitable. If absolute lowest ownership cost and highest reliability are paramount, Japanese alternatives often have a slight edge. However, for the quintessential American V-twin cruiser experience and unmatched customization, the Sportster remains a compelling choice.
Regarding features, the Sportster is quite spartan. Most Japanese rivals from this era, while also largely analog, might offer slightly more refined instrumentation or shaft drive instead of a belt. Modern amenities like ABS or advanced rider aids are absent on the 2005 Sportster, a common trait for bikes of its vintage across brands. The Sportster's "feature" is its iconic styling and immense aftermarket customization potential.
For reliability, the Sportster's Evolution engine is robust, but it can demand more attention to aging gaskets and seals than some Japanese counterparts, which are often lauded for their bulletproof, low-maintenance reliability. However, the Sportster's simplicity often means easier diagnosis and repair for common issues. In terms of price, the Sportster typically commanded a higher new price than comparable Japanese cruisers. In the used market, it generally holds its value better, often selling for a premium due to the Harley-Davidson brand cachet.
Similar Alternatives: The Yamaha V-Star 1100 Custom offers similar cruiser aesthetics and solid performance, often at a slightly lower used price. The Honda Shadow Aero 750 or Spirit 1100 are also strong contenders for reliability and classic looks. The Kawasaki Vulcan 900 Custom provides good value with a modern liquid-cooled engine and comfortable ride.
Better Alternatives: "Better" depends on priorities. For modern features like ABS, fuel injection, and greater refinement, newer bikes from any brand would be superior. For long-distance comfort, larger Harley models (Dyna, Softail, Touring) or touring-oriented Japanese cruisers would be far more suitable. If absolute lowest ownership cost and highest reliability are paramount, Japanese alternatives often have a slight edge. However, for the quintessential American V-twin cruiser experience and unmatched customization, the Sportster remains a compelling choice.
Final Verdict: Is the 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom a Good Motorcycle?
The 2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom is ideal for riders seeking an authentic, classic American V-twin experience without the larger footprint or premium price of bigger Harleys. It appeals to new or intermediate riders, urban commuters, and weekend cruisers who prioritize iconic styling, a distinctive exhaust note, and the brand's heritage. Customization enthusiasts will find it an excellent platform. It's a perfect "second bike" for experienced riders or a primary choice for those valuing tradition over cutting-edge technology.
This model is absolutely worth buying in the used market. Its rubber-mounted Evolution engine significantly improved comfort over older Sportsters, and its robust, simple design promises long-term enjoyment with proper care. Look for a used model with a clear title, documented maintenance history, and minimal deferred maintenance. A pre-purchase inspection is highly recommended. The 1200 Custom trim specifically offers a comfortable, relaxed riding posture with forward controls and a larger fuel tank, making it a desirable variant. Opt for well-maintained examples, ideally with tasteful, reversible customizations, or stock for the best long-term value and reliability.
This model is absolutely worth buying in the used market. Its rubber-mounted Evolution engine significantly improved comfort over older Sportsters, and its robust, simple design promises long-term enjoyment with proper care. Look for a used model with a clear title, documented maintenance history, and minimal deferred maintenance. A pre-purchase inspection is highly recommended. The 1200 Custom trim specifically offers a comfortable, relaxed riding posture with forward controls and a larger fuel tank, making it a desirable variant. Opt for well-maintained examples, ideally with tasteful, reversible customizations, or stock for the best long-term value and reliability.
2005 Harley-Davidson Sportster 1200 Custom Owner Reviews
0.00
Consumer Rating,
Based on 0 Consumer Reviews
Jovan
Jovan specializes in interpreting vehicle records and making sense of VIN data. With over 10 years of experience in the automotive data industry, his work ensures that every report is clear, accurate, and useful for car buyers.