by VIN, Year, Make, Model by License Plate

2009 Toyota Corolla Review: A Redesigned Small Sedan With More Problems Than Other Years

Rating: 4.17
Based on 100 Owner Reviews â–¶
Jovan | March 31, 2025
The 2009 Toyota Corolla is part of the tenth generation (2007-2013) of this iconic compact car. Available as a sedan, it's known for its reliability and fuel efficiency. Key trims included the base, S, LE, and XLE. Pricing ranged approximately from $15,000 to $18,000 when new. Its popularity stems from its reputation for low running costs and dependability, making it a practical choice for budget-conscious buyers.
The Good

The 2009 Corolla excels in reliability and fuel efficiency, appealing to practical buyers. Its comfortable ride and straightforward design offer a sense of familiarity and ease of use. While not a performance car, its dependability provides peace of mind, a key emotional benefit for many owners. Its affordability delivers excellent value.

The Bad

The 2009 Corolla's weaknesses include a somewhat bland interior and uninspired handling. The base engine can feel underpowered, especially with a full load. Watch out for potential oil consumption issues, especially in higher mileage examples. Rust can be a concern in areas with harsh winters, so inspect the undercarriage.

2009 Toyota Corolla: Quick Overview

  • Engine Options: 1.8L inline-4 cylinder
  • Horsepower: 132 hp @ 6000 rpm
  • Fuel Economy:
    • City: 26-27 mpg
    • Highway: 34-35 mpg
  • 0-60 mph: Approximately 9.8 seconds
  • Towing Capacity: Not recommended for towing
  • Trim Level Features:
    • Base: Standard safety features (ABS, airbags), power windows and locks (optional), basic audio system.
    • LE: Adds air conditioning, upgraded audio system, and improved interior trim.
    • S: Sportier styling with body kit, sport seats, and alloy wheels.
    • XLE: Leather upholstery, automatic climate control, premium audio system, and power driver's seat.
  • Transmission: 5-speed manual or 4-speed automatic transmission available
  • Safety Features: Standard anti-lock brakes (ABS), electronic brakeforce distribution (EBD), and multiple airbags including front, side, and curtain airbags. Vehicle Stability Control (VSC) was optional on some trims.
  • Wheels: 15-inch steel wheels standard, alloy wheels available on higher trims.
  • Interior: Cloth upholstery standard on base, LE, and S trims; leather available on XLE.
  • Infotainment: Basic AM/FM radio with CD player standard. Upgraded audio systems with MP3 compatibility available on higher trims. No built-in navigation system.

2009 Toyota Corolla Specifications

Vehicle Information
Year 2009
Make Toyota
Model Corolla
Trim -
Style -
Type Sedan
Category Compact Car
Manufacturing Details
Made In United States
Manufacturing City TOYOTA CITY
Dimensions
Doors 4-Door
Curb Weight 2723 pounds
Gross Vehicle Weight Rating -
Overall Height 57.7 inches
Overall Length 178.7 inches
Overall Width 69.3 inches
Wheelbase Length 102.4 inches
Standard Seating 5
Engine & Performance
Engine Gasoline I4, 1.8-L
Engine Size 1.8L
Engine Cylinders 4
Transmission 4-Speed Automatic
Transmission Type Automatic
Transmission Speeds 4-Speed
Drivetrain Front-Wheel Drive
Additional Features
Anti-Brake System 4-Wheel
Steering Type Power Rack & Pinion
Pricing
Manufacturer Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) $15,350
Invoice Price -
Delivery Charges -

Vehicle History Report

Vehicle
Specifications
Ownership
History
All History
Events
NMVTIS Title
History Check
Salvage/Rebuilt
Check
Accident
Check
Theft
Check
Open Lien
Check
Past Sale
Listings
Safety
Recalls
Odometer
Check
Market Price
Analysis

What Problems Does the 2009 Toyota Corolla Have?

The 2009 Toyota Corolla is generally reliable, but some frequently reported problems include excessive oil consumption, particularly in higher mileage engines. This issue can lead to engine damage if not monitored and addressed. Another concern is premature failure of the mass airflow sensor, which can cause rough idling and poor fuel economy. Some owners have reported issues with the air conditioning system, specifically compressor failures. Rust can also be a problem, especially in regions with salted roads during winter; inspect the undercarriage carefully.

Recalls for the 2009 Corolla mainly concerned issues related to floor mat entrapment of the accelerator pedal, a widespread Toyota recall. Ensure any applicable recalls have been addressed. Long-term reliability concerns primarily revolve around the engine's ability to maintain its performance and efficiency over many years. Regular maintenance, including timely oil changes, is crucial to mitigating potential problems. The 2009 model year is generally regarded as being more reliable than some earlier years of the tenth generation, but these issues should still be considered during inspection.

How long will the 2009 Toyota Corolla last?

With good maintenance habits, a 2009 Toyota Corolla can easily exceed 200,000 miles or provide 15+ years of service. Many owners report reaching 300,000 miles with diligent care. Long-term durability is a strong point, but potential weaknesses include increased oil consumption with age, suspension component wear (struts, bushings), and potential rust issues in colder climates. Regularly checking fluid levels, performing scheduled maintenance, and addressing minor issues promptly are key to maximizing its lifespan. The engine and transmission are typically very robust.
Positive Owner Reviews
JoseC89
This car is my very first. I am happy to start with something small and economic. The trunk as a lot of room, and the interior was clean.
Lynn
This car meets all of our needs. Both my daughter and I will be driving the car. We both enjoy the gas mileage and not having to fill up as often as with our other car.
Magan
My 86 Toyota Corolla died in 2006 when I had to enter it in a monster truck rally because it wouldn't die on its own and I couldn't stomach putting it into a junkyard. 99 Corolla was just as amazing but after a castle nut fell off and the whole axle fell out because of it... I got a free Honda for a while which made me very very sad. In 2009 I bought my Corolla straight off the boat from Japan and it had none of the recalls that all of the other 2009 Corollas had. Living in northern Maine by car was like a billy goat and the battery never died.... Handling was awesome, pick up was superb, every time it ever had a minor mechanical malfunction... It would run for miles and miles and miles until the weather was nice enough for me to fix it. My Corollas were my best friends.... Especially the 86 and the 09. Resale value was very high even though my 09 got totaled in 2019 by an unlicensed and uninsured driver, the insurance company still gave me back almost four grand for it.
Negative Owner Reviews
UWUMASTER
not that great. It would break down every single day and I was stuck with it for 3 months before I got rid of this piece of garbage.
Tiffany
I drive the 2009 Toyota corolla S it drives really good I love the car but the hood paint is messing up and makes the car look poor in the value ... And it's not just my car it's every car I pass in town or at dealerships same make and model

What Technology & Safety Features are Included?

The 2009 Toyota Corolla offered basic tech and entertainment features for its time. Standard models included an AM/FM radio with a CD player. Higher trims added MP3 compatibility and upgraded audio systems. There were no advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) like lane departure warning or blind-spot monitoring available.

Safety features included standard anti-lock brakes (ABS), electronic brakeforce distribution (EBD), and front, side, and curtain airbags. Vehicle Stability Control (VSC) was an optional feature.

Crash test ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) were generally good. The IIHS gave the 2009 Corolla a "Good" rating in most crash tests. The NHTSA awarded it four or five stars in various frontal and side crash tests. Optional features were limited but could include keyless entry, power windows and locks (standard on higher trims), and cruise control. Overall, the Corolla focused on fundamental safety and entertainment rather than cutting-edge technology.

What Colors Options are Available?

Exterior Colors
Super White
Black Sand Pearl
Magnetic Gray Metallic
Silver Streak Mica
Barcelona Red Metallic
Sizzling Crimson Mica
Blue Streak Metallic
Interior Colors
Beige
Light Gray
Dark Charcoal

2009 Toyota Corolla Prices and Market Value

When new, the 2009 Toyota Corolla had an MSRP ranging from approximately $15,000 to $18,000 depending on the trim level. Currently, used market prices typically range from $5,000 to $10,000, contingent on mileage, condition, and location. The Corolla depreciates relatively slowly compared to some competitors, retaining a decent resale value due to its reputation for reliability. Factors affecting resale value include the car's condition (maintenance records, accident history), mileage, trim level (higher trims with more features command higher prices), and overall demand in the used car market.

2009 Toyota Corolla Cost of Ownership

The 2009 Toyota Corolla is very economical to own. Insurance costs are typically low due to its safety record and widespread availability of parts. Fuel economy is excellent. Maintenance costs are generally predictable and affordable, with readily available and reasonably priced parts. Repairs are infrequent and usually straightforward. Long-term ownership costs are among the lowest in its class, making it a smart choice for budget-conscious buyers. It's a very inexpensive car to keep on the road.

2009 Toyota Corolla Fuel Efficiency

Fuel Type Gasoline
Fuel Capacity 13.2 gallons
City Mileage 26 miles/gallon
Highway Mileage 35 miles/gallon

2009 Toyota Corolla Safety Rating

NHTSA
Overall Rating Not Tested
Overall Frontal Star Rating Not Tested
Side Overall Star Rating Not Tested
Overall Rollover Star Rating Not Tested
Combined Front Seat Rating Not Tested
Combined Rear Seat Rating Not Tested
Overall Frontal Star Rating Not Tested
Frontal Barrier Star Ratings Not Tested
Side Barrier Star Ratings Not Tested
Rollover Resistance Star Rating Not Tested

2009 Toyota Corolla Warranty

Basic
Original warranty 36 months / 36,000 miles
Estimated remaining Expired
Corrosion
Original warranty 60 months / unlimited miles
Estimated remaining Expired
Drivetrain
Original warranty 60 months / 60,000 miles
Estimated remaining Expired

2009 Toyota Corolla Insurance

Insurance for a 2009 Toyota Corolla is moderately priced, reflecting its status as a Sedan with strong safety ratings and
reasonable repair costs.

How Does the 2009 Toyota Corolla Compare to Other Sedan?

The 2009 Toyota Corolla competed with the Honda Civic, Mazda3, and Nissan Sentra. In terms of reliability, the Corolla is on par with the Civic and often considered more reliable than the Mazda3 and Sentra. Performance-wise, the Mazda3 offered a more engaging driving experience, while the Corolla prioritized fuel efficiency. Features were comparable across the board, although the Mazda3 often had a slightly sportier interior. Pricing was generally competitive, with the Corolla often being slightly more affordable.

The Honda Civic is a very similar alternative, offering comparable reliability and fuel economy. The Mazda3 is a better choice for those prioritizing driving dynamics. The Nissan Sentra offers more interior space but may not match the Corolla's long-term reliability. Overall, if reliability and low running costs are paramount, the Corolla remains a strong contender. If driving enjoyment is a higher priority, the Mazda3 is a better option. The Civic presents a very similar package.

Ranks #133 Sedan

1 2023 Toyota Camry (5.0★)
2 2023 Honda Accord (0.0★)
3 2023 Lexus ES (0.0★)
4 2024 Subaru Legacy (5.0★)
5 2022 Mazda MX-30 (4.0★)
6 2024 BMW M3 (0.0★)
7 2023 Ford Mustang (5.0★)
8 2023 Mercedes-Benz AMG GT (0.0★)
9 2023 Audi A3 (0.0★)
10 2023 Chevrolet Camaro (5.0★)
11 2023 Hyundai Elantra Hybrid (0.0★)
12 2023 Nissan Altima (4.0★)
133 2009 Toyota Corolla (5.0★)

Final Verdict: Is the 2009 Toyota Corolla a Good Sedan?

The 2009 Toyota Corolla is an ideal choice for budget-minded individuals seeking a reliable and fuel-efficient commuter car. It's worth buying used if a pre-purchase inspection reveals no major issues, especially if maintenance records are available. Opting for an LE or S trim provides a better balance of features without significantly increasing the price. Avoid models with a history of neglect or excessive rust. While not the most exciting car, its dependability and low running costs make it a practical and sensible choice for many.

2009 Toyota Corolla Owner Reviews

4.17
Overall rating
Cancel
Thank You for Your Review!

We truly appreciate the time and effort you took to share your experience with us.

Uh oh!

Something went wrong, please try again later.

UWUMASTER on May 16, 2023

DONT BUY

not that great. It would break down every single day and I was stuck with it for 3 months before I got rid of this piece of garbage.

Was this review helpful?
0
1

JoseC89 on December 7, 2020

First car will see how it goes.

This car is my very first. I am happy to start with something small and economic. The trunk as a lot of room, and the interior was clean.

Was this review helpful?
1
0

Let’s go!!! on November 24, 2020

Commuter’s dream

This car is a commuter’s wish come true. It’s a dependable, great running, high mpg, comfortable vehicle. The car will simply run. Point A to point B without having you question fuel or other operating costs.

Was this review helpful?
1
0

Lynn on November 3, 2020

Very good car,

This car meets all of our needs. Both my daughter and I will be driving the car. We both enjoy the gas mileage and not having to fill up as often as with our other car.

Was this review helpful?
1
0

Magan on August 26, 2020

I've owned 3, and they have all been my favorite

My 86 Toyota Corolla died in 2006 when I had to enter it in a monster truck rally because it wouldn't die on its own and I couldn't stomach putting it into a junkyard. 99 Corolla was just as amazing but after a castle nut fell off and the whole axle fell out because of it... I got a free Honda for a while which made me very very sad. In 2009 I bought my Corolla straight off the boat from Japan and it had none of the recalls that all of the other 2009 Corollas had. Living in northern Maine by car was like a billy goat and the battery never died.... Handling was awesome, pick up was superb, every time it ever had a minor mechanical malfunction... It would run for miles and miles and miles until the weather was nice enough for me to fix it. My Corollas were my best friends.... Especially the 86 and the 09. Resale value was very high even though my 09 got totaled in 2019 by an unlicensed and uninsured driver, the insurance company still gave me back almost four grand for it.

Was this review helpful?
1
0

AlexS on August 21, 2020

Very reliable and comfortable car

Great and comfortable car. Very reliable. I have had it since 2009. It has never left me down or left me stranded. I love my car.

Was this review helpful?
1
0

PirateMikey on August 10, 2020

Great Car!

Excellent vehicle for my needs, upgrade by previous owner to leather interior. AC ice-cold, tires exceptional, engine and entire car super clean. While there are a few minor cosmetic things which I'll take care, of the car is exceptional and a great buy. Ask for Leo!

Was this review helpful?
1
0

Sara53213 on July 31, 2020

Reliable car company, so I know it should last!

We needed a used car for my daughter and this one had a lot of miles on it, but because it's a Toyota, we know that it will still be reliable and great gas mileage! I used to own one 5 years older...I should have just kept it! 🙂

Was this review helpful?
1
0

Toyota Guy on July 30, 2020

The car that wouldn’t quit

This car exceeded my expectations for a commuter car. Daily drive of 120 miles per day and the car never had any issues. At 210,000 miles it still drove like new. Great on gas and did a superb job in the snow with Michelin tires. I was able to go around stuck SUV on back roads without any issues. Not the flashiest and not loaded with all the features but a solid performer and an undisputed value. Very easy to do routine maintenance. Can’t go wrong a Corolla.

Was this review helpful?
1
0

Toyota Corolla 2009 on June 20, 2020

Best value quality

Not driven too much considering the age, most of the time was in parking. Selling because of urgently needing money otherwise would kept it for sure.

Was this review helpful?
1
0
Author Image
Jovan

Jovan specializes in interpreting vehicle records and making sense of VIN data. With over 10 years of experience in the automotive data industry, his work ensures that every report is clear, accurate, and useful for car buyers.